Collection: Grocery, Candy, Snacks, and More!

Click on an icon to jump to a section, or scroll down to see our full offering. Curbside pickup and delivery options available at checkout. Not seeing something? Email us at orders@ithacacoffee.com or call 607-257-2626

929 products
  • $10 After Easter Grab Bag (discount applied at checkout)
    $10 After Easter Grab Bag (discount applied at checkout)
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $17.50
    Unit price
    per 
  • 12 MO. MANCHEGO- PDO by the Pound
    12 MO. MANCHEGO- PDO by the Pound
    Regular price
    $5.24
    Sale price
    $5.24
    Unit price
    per 
  • 2 YEAR CHEDDAR- GRAFTON
    2 YEAR CHEDDAR- GRAFTON
    Regular price
    $7.99
    Sale price
    $7.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • 34 Degrees Original Crisps (4.5oz)
    34 Degrees Original Crisps (4.5oz)
    Regular price
    $5.49
    Sale price
    $5.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • 6 MO. MANCHEGO - P. MAYOR PDO
    6 MO. MANCHEGO - P. MAYOR PDO
    Regular price
    $3.74
    Sale price
    $3.74
    Unit price
    per 
  • 6 MO. MANCHEGO- Pre-Cut
    6 MO. MANCHEGO- Pre-Cut
    Regular price
    $5.00
    Sale price
    $5.00
    Unit price
    per 
  • 88 ACRES DOUBLE CHOCOLATE MOCHA SEED BAR
    88 ACRES DOUBLE CHOCOLATE MOCHA SEED BAR
    Regular price
    $2.29
    Sale price
    $2.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • 88 ACRES TRIPLE BERRY BLEND SEED BAR
    88 ACRES TRIPLE BERRY BLEND SEED BAR
    Regular price
    $2.29
    Sale price
    $2.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • ABBA HERRING MUSTARD JAR
    ABBA HERRING MUSTARD JAR
    Regular price
    $5.49
    Sale price
    $5.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • ABTEY ROYAL LIQUER DARK CHOC
    ABTEY ROYAL LIQUER  DARK CHOC
    Regular price
    $19.99
    Sale price
    $19.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ABTEY WHISKEY RUM DARK CHOC
    ABTEY WHISKEY RUM DARK CHOC
    Regular price
    $17.99
    Sale price
    $17.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • Adirondack Summer Sausage 10 oz.
    Adirondack Summer Sausage 10 oz.
    Regular price
    $8.99
    Sale price
    $8.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • AFRIKA DARK CHOCOLATE
    AFRIKA DARK CHOCOLATE
    Regular price
    $4.49
    Sale price
    $4.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • AKMAK ARMENIAN CRACKER BREAD
    AKMAK ARMENIAN CRACKER BREAD
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $3.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • ALEXIAN OLIVE OIL CRACKERS
    ALEXIAN OLIVE OIL CRACKERS
    Regular price
    $4.49
    Sale price
    $4.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • ALMONDINA ORIGINAL 4 oz. Bag
    ALMONDINA ORIGINAL 4 oz. Bag
    Regular price
    $3.79
    Sale price
    $3.79
    Unit price
    per 
  • AMARULA GOLDKENN 100G
    AMARULA GOLDKENN 100G
    Regular price
    $7.99
    Sale price
    $7.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • Amy's Kitchen Organic Soups
    Amy's Kitchen Organic Soups
    Regular price
    $4.99
    Sale price
    $4.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ANGOSTURA BITTERS 4 OZ
    ANGOSTURA BITTERS 4 OZ
    Regular price
    $11.99
    Sale price
    $11.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ANGOSTURA ORANGE BITTERS 4 oz
    ANGOSTURA ORANGE BITTERS  4 oz
    Regular price
    $12.99
    Sale price
    $12.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ANNAS ALMOND THINS
    ANNAS ALMOND THINS
    Regular price
    $2.95
    Sale price
    $2.95
    Unit price
    per 
  • ANNAS GINGER THINS
    ANNAS GINGER THINS
    Regular price
    $2.95
    Sale price
    $2.95
    Unit price
    per 
  • AQUA VITEA ELDERBERRY
    AQUA VITEA ELDERBERRY
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $4.39
    Unit price
    per 
  • AQUA VITEA PINEAPPLE LEMONADE
    AQUA VITEA PINEAPPLE LEMONADE
    Regular price
    $4.39
    Sale price
    $4.39
    Unit price
    per 
  • AQUA VITEA STRAWBERRY SAGE
    AQUA VITEA STRAWBERRY SAGE
    Regular price
    $4.39
    Sale price
    $4.39
    Unit price
    per 
  • ARBOR HILL NIAGRA JELLY
    ARBOR HILL NIAGRA JELLY
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $6.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • Ariston Balsamic 250ml
    Ariston Balsamic 250ml
    Regular price
    $11.99
    Sale price
    $11.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ARISTON GREEN OLIVES
    ARISTON GREEN OLIVES
    Regular price
    $3.99
    Sale price
    $3.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • Ariston Olive Oil 500 ml
    Ariston Olive Oil 500 ml
    Regular price
    $12.99
    Sale price
    $12.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASBACH BOTTLE INDIVIDUAL
    ASBACH BOTTLE INDIVIDUAL
    Regular price
    $0.99
    Sale price
    $0.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASBACH BRANDY BEANS
    ASBACH BRANDY BEANS
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $9.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASBACH CHERRIES INDIVDUAL CHERRY
    ASBACH CHERRIES INDIVDUAL CHERRY
    Regular price
    $0.99
    Sale price
    $0.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASBACH KAFFEE PRALINEN
    ASBACH KAFFEE PRALINEN
    Regular price
    $10.99
    Sale price
    $10.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASHER MILK CHOC PNT BUTTER EGG
    ASHER MILK CHOC PNT BUTTER EGG
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $1.69
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASIAGO- STELLA
    ASIAGO- STELLA
    Regular price
    $3.24
    Sale price
    $3.24
    Unit price
    per 
  • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI
    ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI
    Regular price
    $4.79
    Sale price
    $4.79
    Unit price
    per 
  • BABY GOUDA- JAKE'S
    BABY GOUDA- JAKE'S
    Regular price
    $5.74
    Sale price
    $5.74
    Unit price
    per 
  • BACK TO NATURE CLASSIC ROUND
    BACK TO NATURE CLASSIC ROUND
    Regular price
    $4.49
    Sale price
    $4.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • BACON PEPPER DIP TERRAPIN
    BACON PEPPER DIP TERRAPIN
    Regular price
    $7.99
    Sale price
    $7.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAHLSEN BITTERSWEET CHOCOLATE LEIBNIZ COOKIES
    BAHLSEN BITTERSWEET CHOCOLATE LEIBNIZ COOKIES
    Regular price
    $4.49
    Sale price
    $4.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAHLSEN BUTTER LEAVES
    BAHLSEN BUTTER LEAVES
    Regular price
    $3.29
    Sale price
    $3.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAHLSEN CHOC ICED PFEFFERNUSSE
    BAHLSEN CHOC ICED PFEFFERNUSSE
    Regular price
    $4.39
    Sale price
    $4.39
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAHLSEN CHOCO LEIBNIZ CARAMEL
    BAHLSEN CHOCO LEIBNIZ CARAMEL
    Regular price
    $4.49
    Sale price
    $4.49
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAHLSEN LEIBNIZ BUTTER BISCUIT
    BAHLSEN LEIBNIZ BUTTER BISCUIT
    Regular price
    $3.13
    Sale price
    $3.13
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAI BLUEBERRY 18OZ
    BAI BLUEBERRY 18OZ
    Regular price
    $2.29
    Sale price
    $2.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAI DRAGONFRUIT 18OZ
    BAI DRAGONFRUIT 18OZ
    Regular price
    $2.29
    Sale price
    $2.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAI MOLOKAI COCONUT 18OZ
    BAI MOLOKAI COCONUT 18OZ
    Regular price
    $2.29
    Sale price
    $2.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAI POMEGRANATE 18OZ
    BAI POMEGRANATE 18OZ
    Regular price
    $2.29
    Sale price
    $2.29
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAILEYS CHOCOLATE TWISTS
    BAILEYS CHOCOLATE TWISTS
    Regular price
    $5.99
    Sale price
    $5.99
    Unit price
    per 
  • BAKE AT HOME ICC APRICOT OAT SCONES (ROUND OF 6)
    BAKE AT HOME ICC APRICOT OAT SCONES (ROUND OF 6)
    Regular price
    $12.99
    Sale price
    $12.99
    Unit price
    per